Yes, mortgage lenders generally consider student loans in forbearance when evaluating a borrower’s debt-to-income ratio.
If you need details
When considering a borrower’s eligibility for a mortgage, lenders typically take into account various factors, including the borrower’s debt-to-income ratio. One significant component of this ratio is the borrower’s student loans, whether they are in forbearance or not. Mortgage lenders do consider student loans in forbearance as part of the calculation, potentially impacting the borrower’s ability to qualify for a mortgage or affecting the terms of the loan.
Including student loans in forbearance while evaluating a borrower’s debt-to-income ratio is a common practice among mortgage lenders. This is because even though the borrower might not be actively making payments during forbearance, the outstanding student loan balance still represents a long-term financial obligation. By factoring in the potential future payments when evaluating the borrower’s financial situation, lenders aim to assess the borrower’s ability to handle additional debt responsibly.
It is worth noting that the treatment of student loans in forbearance can vary slightly depending on the mortgage lender and the specific loan program. Some lenders may consider a specific percentage of the balance owed, while others may take the standard monthly payment associated with the loan into account. Additionally, different loan programs may have specific guidelines regarding student loans in forbearance. Therefore, it is essential for borrowers to communicate openly with their lenders to understand how forbearance impacts their mortgage application.
A quote from financial expert Dave Ramsey provides valuable insight into the consideration of student loans in forbearance by mortgage lenders: “Never count on mortgage lenders to accurately calculate your ability to afford a home. They may let you borrow more than you should, in which case you’ll be house poor. Or they may include only your base student loan payment, which would inflate the amount of home you can afford.”
To provide a concise overview, here are some interesting facts about student loans in forbearance:
- Forbearance allows borrowers to temporarily pause or reduce their student loan payments due to financial hardship.
- During forbearance, interest may continue to accrue, potentially increasing the overall loan balance.
- Different types of forbearance options are available, including general forbearance, economic hardship forbearance, and administrative forbearance.
- Student loans in forbearance can impact various aspects of financial life, including qualifying for a mortgage, credit score, and long-term financial planning.
- It is crucial for borrowers in forbearance to remain vigilant and maintain open communication with their lenders to understand how it might affect different financial situations.
Table: Example Calculation of Debt-to-Income Ratio with Student Loans in Forbearance
| Monthly Income | $5,000 |
| Monthly Debt (excluding student loans) | $1,200 |
| Monthly Student Loan Payment (before forbearance) | $300 |
| Ratio without considering student loans | 24% |
| Ratio considering student loans in forbearance | 30% |
Note: The values in the table are for illustrative purposes only and do not reflect specific loan terms or borrower situations.
In conclusion, mortgage lenders generally count student loans in forbearance when evaluating a borrower’s debt-to-income ratio since these loans represent a long-term financial obligation. Borrowers should communicate openly with their lenders and understand how forbearance might impact their mortgage application. Remember that individual lender guidelines and specific loan programs can influence how student loans in forbearance are considered. It’s vital to stay informed and consult with professionals when navigating the intersection of student loans and mortgage applications.
In the YouTube video titled “Do Mortgage Lenders Have to Count My Student Loan Payments Against Me?”, Linda Davidson, a mortgage lender, explains that most mortgage types, such as conventional, FHA, VA, and USDA loans, require lenders to consider borrowers’ student loan payments, even if they are deferred or in forbearance. These guidelines are in place to secure loan insurance from the respective organizations. Davidson emphasizes the need for accurate debt-to-income ratio calculations and upfront inclusion of student loans, regardless of their current status. For further information or assistance, she provides contact details.
There are other opinions on the Internet
Additionally, if the student loan is in deferment or forbearance and the credit report reflects a monthly payment (even if this payment is an estimated payment amount), lenders may use this payment to qualify the borrower.
If you have student loans that are currently in forbearance, mortgage lenders will treat you as a greater risk, even though your monthly student loan obligation is less during the forbearance period. Using the 1% rule, mortgage underwriters will assume that your monthly student loan payment is $1,500, which may reduce the maximum monthly housing payment you qualify for. However, your mortgage lender is required to factor in either 0.5% of the remaining balance of your student loans if your current monthly payment is $0, the monthly payment listed on your credit report, or the actual payment as indicated on your student loan statement.
Even though her monthly student loan obligation is less (zero, in fact) during the CARES Act forbearance, mortgage lenders will treat her as a greater risk. Using the 1% rule, mortgage underwriters will assume that her monthly student loan payment is $1,500. As a result, she may now only qualify for a maximum monthly housing payment of $600.
However, if your loans are in forbearance or deferred, or you’re on an income-driven repayment plan, your mortgage lender is required to factor in either: 0.5 percent of the remaining balance of your student loans if your current monthly payment is $0; the monthly payment listed on your credit report; or the actual payment as indicated on your student loan statement.
I am confident that you will be interested in these issues
FHA uses the payment listed on the credit report or account statement, but if the loan is deferred or forbearance, the lender will use 0.5% of the outstanding balance.